To have an enforceable contract, the parties need to agree on essential terms. This typically includes price and scope of work. A recent case demonstrates how the lack of essential terms can impact the enforceability of a contract including an arbitration provision.
In Diamond Edge Construction, LLC v. The Moorings of Pinellas County Condominium Association, Inc., 51 Fla. L. Weekly D2288d (Fla. 2d DCA 2026), a contractor submitted a contract to an Association to address hurricane related water damage to 40 condominium units. The contract was not signed by the Association. The contract included an arbitration provision. However, the contract did not include price or even scope of work. The Association ended up paying the contractor north of $800,000 (although the scope of work was unclear) before the Association learned the contractor was not licensed. The Association terminated the contractor and filed a lawsuit. The contractor moved to compel arbitration based on its contract.
Arbitration is a creature of contract so the first inquiry in analyzing any motion to compel arbitration is whether there is an enforceable contract to arbitrate. Here, even though the contract was not signed by the Association, the lack of signature by the Association was not the driving issue because “whether a valid agreement to exists does not necessarily require an arbitration agreement to be executed.” Diamond Edge Construction, supra (citing authority explaining that the conduct of the parties can demonstrate their intent to be bound by an enforceable contract).
Here, the unsigned contract could serve as evidence of a valid agreement. But the contract was devoid of essential terms regarding price and scope. While the Association did pay the contractor, there was nothing connecting the payment to the contract, meaning it was unclear why the money was paid or what the contractor was paid for. Thus, as the appellate court found:
We are then only left with the unsigned Agreement. Our review of that Agreement convinces us that the parties had not agreed on essential terms, namely the scope of the work to be performed and the construction price to be paid. In such circumstances, we have concluded that an agreement is not enforceable as the agreement was simply, at best, an agreement to agree.
Diamond Edge Construction, supra (citation omitted).
When finalizing a contract, make sure there is an agreement or mechanism, clarified by the contract, as to the essential terms. This will typically include an agreed-upon scope of work and the price for the scope of work. The objective is to have an enforceable contract, not an agreement to agree.
Please contact David Adelstein at dadelstein@gmail.com or (954) 361-4720 if you have questions or would like more information regarding this article. You can follow David Adelstein on Twitter @DavidAdelstein1.

